I agree with all that stuff you said SKB., I must have said at least 1000 times 'Quran is NOT word of allah/god neither all of that you see in Quran was said by Muhammad ., Like Hadith this book was also put together by Muhammad followers 10s of years after the death of Muhammad. So I have no disagreement with you there.skynightblaze wrote:
Ofcourse hadiths were written after the death of muhammad. I am not saying they are all accurate but saying that they are all made up is equally silly which is what CAT is arguing. As I said if they all made up stories to corrupt islam then one must forget about quran . People who can forge scriptures like hadiths, sira can easily forge quran . Infact the case for corruption of quran becomes stronger when one says that hadiths have been forged because as a corrupt person one would first aim at quran and then other scriptures because quran is the main book of islam.You are a hypocrite if you believe only in quran and reject the hadiths completely because by the virtue of your own arguments you debunk quran too along with debunking hadiths .
What all I am saying is, as a belief /religious belief/cult ., whatever you call, Followers of Muhammad have the right to choose what they think is right for them ad their islam. So some Muslim think Quran is the best way to go. That doesn't mean you are NOT allowed to question their belief. I am saying that because of your words
I understand as a Non-Muslim or as an atheist "you have rejected everything In Islam" , But for those who believe in Islam have the right to choose Quran as the only Islamic religious doctrine" and rest are silly junk stories. off course people like you will still have the freedom to question Islam/Quran/Muhammad.We do have hadiths where muhammad himself asked down to write what he said .Anyway there cant be a case for quran only muslim. Either you accept all the junk or reject all . All the arguments that he brought have already been answered.