Ibn Kammuna (13th century)

This section of the forum is NOT for discussions. It is a database of documents, websites, books and other resources, to provide skeptics with the materials to compose their articles refuting Islam. Please place your links in the appropriate thread. If your material needs a new thread, please advise me first. We do not want to clutter this DB with too many threads that may be similar. Do not copy and paste. Give full references and make sure the source is reliable. If you want to rebut any of the documents posted here, use another thread in other sections of the forum.
Post Reply
Posts: 271
Joined: Sat Jun 27, 2009 12:32 am

Ibn Kammuna (13th century)

Post by Robert »

From Wikipedia:
Sa'd ibn Mansur (Izz Al-dawla) Ibn Kammuna (died 1284) was a 13th Century Jewish physician (ophthalmologist), philosopher and dissenter of Islam who lived under the rule of the Mongols in Baghdad.

As a prolific scholar he played an important role in the diffusion of new thought in the Middle East. Much of his legacy, contained in the form of commentaries, correspondence, and treatise still survives today and makes up part of the historical remnants of his time.


Ibn Kammuna's commentary on Shahab al-Din Suhrawardi's Talwihat, the core text of Illuminationist philosophy is deemed as one of the most thorough examination of that branch of thought.

His comparative treatise on the three monotheistic religions Christianity, Judaism and Islam, titled Examination of the Three Faiths challenged the legitimacy of Islam where he reasoned that incompatibility of sharia with the principles of justice undercuts Muhammad's claims of being a perfect man and stated that people convert to Islam from ulterior motives.[1][2]

"That is why, to this day we never see anyone converting to Islam unless in terror, or in quest of power, or to avoid heavy taxation, or to escape humiliation, or if taken prisoner, or because of infatuation with a Muslim woman, or for some similar reason. Nor do we see a respected, wealthy, and pious non-Muslim well versed in both his faith and that of Islam, going over to the Islamic faith without some of the aforementioned or similar motives." [3][1]

He goes on to regard the Prophet Muhammad "unoriginal" and "imperfect".

"We will not concede that Muhammad added to the knowledge of God and of obedience to him anything more than what was found in the earlier religions."[unreliable source?][2]

"There is no proof that Muhammad attained perfection and the ability to perfect others as claimed."[1][2]

The publication of the book caused rioting in Baghdad, forcing kammuna to flee that city in secret and was recorded by the thirteenth century historian Ibn al-Fuwati.

"In this year 1284 it became known in Baghdad that the Jew Ibn Kammuna had written a volume in which he displayed impudence in the discussion of the prophecies. God keep us from repeating what he said. The infuriated mob rioted, and massed to attack his house and to kill him. The amir...and a group of high officials rode forth to the Mustansiriya madrassa, and summoned the supreme judge and the law teachers to hold a hearing on the affair. They sought Ibn Kammuna but he was in hiding. That day happened to be a Friday. The supreme judge set out for the prayer service but as the mob blocked him, he returned to the Mustansirya. The amir stepped out to calm the crowds but these showered abuse upon him and accused him of being on the side of Ibn Kammuna, and of defending him. Then, upon the amir’s order, ii was heralded in Baghdad that, early the following morning outside the city wall, lbn Kammuna would be burned. The mob subsided, and no further reference to Ibn Kammuna was made. As for lbn Kammuna, he was put into a leather-covered box and carried to Hilla where his son was then serving as official. There he stayed for a time until he died."[4][2]


The Arabic Treatise on the Immortality of the Soul by Sa'd ibn Mansur ibn Kammuna
An Overview of Investigations into the Views of the Three Faiths
Commentary on Ibn Sina's al-Isharat wa 'l-tanbihat.
Ibn Kammunah's Treatise on the Differences between the Rabbanites and the Karaites'
Purjavadi, Reza. A Jewish Philosopher of Baghdad: Izz Al-dawla Ibn Kammuna (D. 683/1284) and His Writings (Brill Academic Publishers, 2006)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ibn_Kammuna" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

Post Reply