Re: Are these hadiths true WittyBoy?
Posted: Sat Nov 06, 2010 12:13 pm
So what do we have here?? we have Ghalibkhastahaal reply and we have MesMorial supporting Ghalib and answering all question of that Blazing Skynight
Welcome to FFI dear MesMorial
with best wishes
yeezevee
Welcome to FFI dear MesMorial
And I too understand what The Cat would like to do with Islam but I have the right to doubt and question The Cat's intentions and the out come in the real world dear Ghalib. On the similar basis of authenticity of some words in Quran and other Islamic manuals, Islam already split in to many sects including that Bahá'u'lláh sect of nineteenth-century Persia. So at best The Cat and cat likes is going to make another sect of Islam and that is O.K. with me. ., The condition is simple and I highlighted here at viewtopic.php?f=21&t=8268&p=130520#p130520" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;Ghalibkhastahaal wrote:I do understand you concern but one must accept what the poster has declared.yeezevee wrote:Well The Cat is trying to invent some antibiotic to Viral Islam using Quran itself by juggling some surahs around dear Ghalibkhastahaal. During that exploratory process he appears to make some mistakes and he appears to be playing in to wrong hands. You see above he says contradictory statements.You see once you make a book as sacred code of laws and IMPOSE ON OTHERS then you have a clash and you will have a problem. And in the History of "Muhammad's Islam" That is what Islam did and Quran has verses in support of that." I never did endorse its authenticity nor its legitimacy" and I deal with it as -their- sacred code of laws .
That doesn't mean Quran/Muhammad "the prophet of Islam" escapes criticism from those whose cultures were uprooted by Muhammad following Muslims. Even for an intellectual discussion on religions, Quran has enough nonsense and exposes criminal activities of Muhammad (real or Imaginary) in its verses. So critics will continue to high light that . Muslims must learn to EAT IT AND LIVE WITH IT, unless a Muslims ruler like Caliph stumps at freedom of expression and freedom to inquire the so-called religious scriptures 'Quran", the critics will continue to highlight problems in the Past and present Islam & criticize 'Quran"/Muhammad....yeezevee wrote: "That book, Quran is NOT a law", at least not a law for human beings to enforce. Assuming, it being the word of Allah/god whatever, only Allah/god or messengers/prophets of Allah should deal with those who don't follow the rules/laws that are there in Quran. In the present times all messengers being DEAD and no more messengers from allah/god are going to come, the followers of the messengers should NOT have any role in enforcing the laws of Quran
You are welcome dear Ghalib., Off course I am concerned about Muslims as well as Non-Muslims. You do belong to one of those two groups ..don't you.. lol..Thanks for your concern.
with best wishes
yeezevee