Page 2 of 2

Re: When Asked Why Jews are Cursed, Muslims Answer...

PostPosted: Sat Feb 06, 2016 5:38 am
by Garudaman
Hombre wrote:
Garudaman wrote:
glitch wrote:If there are no examples of Jews killing prophets, even in the koran, doesn't that make the Koran invalid?

no, because no example doesn't mean there's no event (absence of evidence isn't evidence of absence)!
fact is a fact is a fact - regardless how one tries to render it in differ color or light.

yeah, & the reality is, there's no fact which shows Jews never killed prophets, regardless how one tries to render it in differ color or light!

Hombre wrote:glich is absolutely right. Jews do not kill their own children for some hollow ego. They are smarter then that.

from the beginning until now, wherever the place, criminals are always refusing the truth, & usually also accompanied by killing the person who convey it!

Re: When Asked Why Jews are Cursed, Muslims Answer...

PostPosted: Sat Feb 06, 2016 5:48 am
by pr126
What a planet! 80% of Allah creations are criminals for not believing in him.

It goes like this.
I (Allah) will create may infidels for Muslims to kill, so they can prove their devotion to me.
I will reward them for the killing. All those who do not worship me, will end up in a lake of fire.

This is a perfect religion. For murderous psychopaths.

Quran 5:3 This day have I perfected your religion for you and completed My favour unto you, and have chosen for you as religion al-Islam.

Thanks, Muhammad. Good work.

Re: When Asked Why Jews are Cursed, Muslims Answer...

PostPosted: Mon Feb 08, 2016 8:00 am
by Garudaman
pr126 wrote:What a planet! 80% of Allah creations are criminals for not believing in him.

so, you want to say that the true nature of human (what exactly that human want) is evil?

pr126 wrote:I (Allah) will create may infidels for Muslims to kill, so they can prove their devotion to me.

infidel who fight muslim (QS. 22:39, QS. 4:88-92) or infidel who fight any innocent (QS. 4:75)!

pr126 wrote:Quran 5:3 This day have I perfected your religion for you and completed My favour unto you, and have chosen for you as religion al-Islam.

Thanks, Muhammad. Good work.

viewtopic.php?f=22&t=14704&p=194459#p194459

"Islam" = any religion which doesn't contradict with knowledge of it follower!

;)

Re: When Asked Why Jews are Cursed, Muslims Answer...

PostPosted: Mon Feb 08, 2016 9:58 am
by sum
Koran chapter 9 is Koran 5:3 in action and what the Islamic perfection is.

sum

Re: When Asked Why Jews are Cursed, Muslims Answer...

PostPosted: Tue Feb 09, 2016 5:06 pm
by glitch
Garudaman wrote:
glitch wrote:If there are no examples of Jews killing prophets, even in the koran, doesn't that make the Koran invalid?

no, because no example doesn't mean there's no event (absence of evidence isn't evidence of absence)!


If I point out and call every female who walks around me a whore, am I allowed to do that without evidence?

I don't believe I am, nor can I say, "Well I have no evidence, but that doesn't mean they aren't whores..." YES, it does mean that.

You can't make a claim that the Jews are cursed for killing prophets when there are no examples. I'm sorry that's a baseless, overreaching claim that requires evidence. That is the Koran's one claim of the invalidity of the Jews and if there is no answer and no example, it isn't true.

Re: When Asked Why Jews are Cursed, Muslims Answer...

PostPosted: Wed Feb 10, 2016 1:31 am
by Hombre
glitch wrote:News Flash: There's only one death at the Hands of Jews: Jesus.
I thought back in 1986, the late Pope John Paul II, had put this nonsense to rest, and exonerated Jews from this crime.

It was the Romes who ruled Jerusalem, were the ones who crucified not only Jesus - anyone who stood in their way. Beside, all throughout their 4000 year history, there is no single evidence Jews used crucification to execute anyone - even the condemned ones.

Re: When Asked Why Jews are Cursed, Muslims Answer...

PostPosted: Wed Feb 10, 2016 4:42 am
by glitch
Hombre wrote:
glitch wrote:News Flash: There's only one death at the Hands of Jews: Jesus.
I thought back in 1986, the late Pope John Paul II, had put this nonsense to rest, and exonerated Jews from this crime.

It was the Romes who ruled Jerusalem, were the ones who crucified not only Jesus - anyone who stood in their way. Beside, all throughout their 4000 year history, there is no single evidence Jews used crucification to execute anyone - even the condemned ones.


1. This isn't about blaming the jews.
2. this is about the islamic claim they killed prophets, bt the only example that can be pointed to is either jesus or Stephen.
3. i wasn't aware that muslims recognized Stephen as a prophet since he preached Jesus to be God.
4. For them to claim Jesus as an example means we must ignore the very statements of the Koran, that he wasn't killed.

The Koran invalidate itself period.